Tim O’Neil


Tim O’Neil

Title:  Top Producer – Broker Associate Realtor

Agent MLS ID:  638511208


Toll Free:  888-688-7137

Cell Phone:  727-687-2232

The Peoples’ Realtor

From Tim’s Managing Broker at Plumlee Gulf Beach Realty – I encourage you to read Tim’s full resume, but you can quickly learn the true insight on Tim from this note from Rosana, Tim’s recent customer:

Hello, Mr. Breland. Thank you! It’s been a long process but thank you to Mr. O’Neil. He has been a very professional Realtor to work with, and he’s helped me a lot. In my situation, I just lost my husband suddenly in 2020, only it’s been very hard for our family. Thank you to Mr. O’Neil. He’s an Angel to me and my children. I will refer him to all my friends. Thank you so much and have a very nice weekend. More power to your Team.

Rosana, Seller October 2021

Tim is consistently THE Top producing Realtor at Plumlee Gulf Beach Realty with a remarkable track record of success here since 2004. Stellar MLS data confirms Tim has closed over 500 transaction sides valued at $132 million through 2023 – with the highest individual property sale at $5 million. He takes personal and attentive care of his customers to guide them through all types of real estate markets.


Tim’s Track Record of Success for his Customers

Click the link to open the latest PDF report on – – Tim’s 2023 Market Share Report.

Here’s how one of Tim’s client’s described her real estate experience “Tim was referred by my niece based upon his great efforts to help her find and purchase their first home in Largo. He spent nearly a year working with them. As for me, Tim listened to the things I was looking for and chose homes to show me based upon those items. It only took 1 day and 9 showings for me to find the perfect home. Tim negotiated with the seller to get me a price very close my offer. He was very responsive to the lending agency during the process, as well as assisting me after the closing, via phone and emails.”

Tim says he feels real estate is “his calling”. He came to Florida specifically to go into the real estate business from Canandaigua, NY in 2003 after a successful career as Sales Manager with a retail clothing chain and as a successful real estate broker. Tim’s years of experience in New York qualified him to immediately apply to be a Florida Broker.

His clients and friends nicknamed have him “The Peoples Realtor” because of his great people skills when doing property deals. It makes him feel happy to help his clients. He has a natural gift for really digging into a neighborhood to really get to know an area. He becomes an expert and loves to share that knowledge with his clients. He’s totally at home with the fast paced nature of real estate and his reward comes from the positive results he generates for his clients.



August 2016

It was great working with Tim as the Co-operating Realtor on the sales of his listing for my Buyer.

Jean F, Realtor

Feb 2017

I wanted to thank you again for all your hard work and diligence in pursuing the sale of this property. I have worked in several areas of the real estate business over the last 15 years, and I have rarely seen a Realtor work so hard and be so persistent. Some agents would have bowed out on a challenging sale like ours – when not allowed access to the property. Most would have said enough is enough when called to testify in court. I’m not even sure when you were first asked to get involved with this sale, but this was quite a process. You saw this one through to the end and had it sold in less than a month on the market. Way to go the extra distance. GREAT JOB! .

Thomas. J Cristello, SunTrust

Feb 2017

As far as feedback on Tim. I will preface my comments with the thought that everyone is different and has different needs – and Tim has the skills to help different buyers and sellers. Tim was perfect for me because he was there when I needed him without holding my hand (which I don’t need). In other words he was easy going (which I do need), and I would whole heartedly recommend him.

Gloria Larson

August 2017

Thank you so much for helping us with getting our new home. We really love it!!!

Jane and Mike, Buyers

September 2018

Thank you…. The bottom line is – We will always will use Tim for our real estate needs. I recommend you do too.

Eddie and Beverly, Sellers

September 2018

Tim was very diligent in finding me the best home to meet my needs. I originally actually planned to work with the Realtor that sold my previous home. In the end I decided to go with Tim because of how hard he worked for me. I will definitely refer Tim to friends and family.

Patricia, Buyer

July 2019

It was great working with Tim, makes all the difference when you work with an experienced Realtor.

Carole, Realtor

November 2019

I bought this condo from Tim and have worked with him multiple times over the years with rentals and sales and when I was President of the board of one of the condos. I naturally went back to Tim to sell this condo. If there is anything I know about Tim it’s that he will find a way to make the sale while always remaining professional. This latest sale was held up by the lender’s concerns about a litigation against the association. Tim convinced the lender to take another look at the facts of the specific case; and their concerns disappeared. I recommend Tim to anyone wishing to buy or sell. I know he will work hard to find a way to not only sell quickly but also get you the best price. Back in 2007 when everyone was moaning and groaning about how bad the market was, Tim was still out there taking care of his customers making sales on a regular basis.

Barry, Seller

September 2020

Thank you for your excellent care in all our real estate endeavors. It’s always a been pleasure working with you on our many transactions. We are enjoying our incredible housewarming gift in our new condo. We are getting settled but loving it already. Thanks for making them all possible.

Chris and Leola, Buyers

July 2021

Tim did a great job! He was actively working on our behalf every day – even making calls on his days off. He made it easy for us, and it was a pleasure working with him.

Terry and Tad, Sellers

July 2021

You are “The #1, A+ Realtor” and I will always remember you for future sales. Thanks for being so kind!

Shirley, Sellers

September 2021

You did it for us again, Tim! Thank you so much for all of your hard work. We are so happy to finally have our dream beach vacation rental. We truly appreciate you and will remain your friends always!

Tom and Maria, Buyers

December 2021

As I told your Manager when we met in your office – to work together with Tim (and of course Plumlee) was very satisfying. Tim was very engaged, offered a lot of support and I definitely will recommend him to my friends when they are in the same or similar situation like I have been. One more time – thank you, and have a happy and healthy New Year in 2022 – and always think “life is good”.

Wolfgang, Seller

February 2022

Tim is an exceptional Realtor. He went above and beyond helping us find our perfect home. Tim helped us explore different options and weigh the pros and cons. We definitely recommend Tim to others interested in finding their perfect home.

Belinda and Ed, Buyers

March 2022

Just want you to know, Tim is the best Realtor anyone could ask for. I asked him for special properties. He found what I wanted, and we closed 5 days later! Now that’s quality service – and in this market, Wow, he is tops!! I always recommend Tim to anyone who needs a great Realtor. I will continue to work with Tim. Thank you again.

Bryan, Buyer

April 2022

This is our fourth transaction with Tim, and he’s now looking for our next property. We met Tim in 2012 and since then he’s been someone we 110% rely on. He knows the market, is very tenacious and works hard for his clients. The man can negotiate! When we couldn’t get to Florida to sell our house due to Covid, Tim went above and beyond. Our tenant was less than respectful to our property, and we needed extensive repairs. Tim arranged it all and made sure the work was done well. We recently found out he and his family took their own time (and truck) to personally remove some of the stuff left by the tenant. We don’t know of anyone else who would ever go above and beyond like that! What we would say to another buyer or seller is that Tim won’t stop until you get what you want, and you’ll have a few laughs along the way! We’d be so appreciative if you could let Plumlee’s Broker Owner know how delighted we are with our experience(s). We’ll be back as soon as he finds us our next piece of Florida heaven!

Tine and Stephen, Buyers