(800) 926-9489

The Most Tempting Desserts in Indian Rocks Beach

The Most Tempting Desserts in Indian Rocks Beach

Who loves a good dessert? We sure do! That’s why we’re highlighting a few of the best desserts in Indian Rocks Beach, Florida and where you can find them. This is not an all-inclusive list, but a great place to get started. All of these options are not far from your Indian Rocks Beach vacation rental. Get out there and try some of these local favorites. Let us know which ones you try and which best satisfy your sweet tooth. Enjoy! 

Carrot cake drizzled with caramel from TJ's Italian Cafe | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach Rentals

Carrot Cake Drizzled with Caramel

@TJ’s Italian Café

Chef TJ makes some of the most amazing homemade cakes that are to die for. This carrot cake drizzled with caramel is just one of the many mouthwatering examples. Ask about the cakes when you’re here for a meal. They are not necessarily on the menu, but they are one of the best kept secrets in Indian Rocks Beach. 

Huge chocolate cake slice from Crabby Bill's | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach Rentals

Crabby Bill’s Chocolate Cake

@The Original Crabby Bill’s Indian Rocks Beach

This massive slice of chocolate cake is literally 1/4 of the entire cake. If you check out the reviews on TripAdvisor and Google, you’ll see that this chocolate cake is famous. Give it a try next time you’re here. You can also order cakes and cookies through Crabby Bill’s IRB Gift Shop from their bakery, Pipo & Betty’s

Classic Belgian Waffle Piled High with Fresh Fruit and Homemade Whipped Cream at Sweet Sage Cafe | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach Rentals

The Waffledaffle (Classic Belgian Waffle) 

@Sweet Sage Café

The Waffledaffle from the Sweet Sage Café is a classic Belgian waffle piled high with fresh fruit and whipped cream, just as it should be! Whether you call it breakfast or dessert, it doesn’t really matter as long as you try it next time you’re here. The café serves breakfast and lunch, is very dog-friendly, and even has doggie dishes on their Canine Cuisine menu. 

Elvis Peanut Butter Sundae from Lu Lu's Ice Cream Shop | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach Rentals

Elvis Peanut Butter Sundae 

@Lu Lu’s Ice Cream Shop

Lu Lu’s is a whimsical shop that will bring a smile to your face with all your favorites including handmade ice cream, pies, cakes, floats, shakes and sundaes. You really can’t go wrong no matter what you choose, but this Elvis Peanut Butter Sundae is very tempting. Also be sure to check out their nostalgic candy and vintage inspired toys. Here’s a coupon for your next visit.

Gluten-free Cappuccino Mousse Pie | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach rentals

Gluten-Free Cappuccino Mousse Pie

@Villa Gallace

Villa Gallace Italian Restaurant is a wonderful choice for dinner, but don’t forget to save room for a homemade dessert. You’ll regret it if you don’t. Take a look at this gluten-free Cappuccino Mousse Pie and keep it in mind next time you’re dining here. Just remember to make a reservation in advance. 

Tiramisu from Mike's Pizza and Pub | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach rentals

Tiramisu Drizzled with Chocolate

@Mike’s Pizza & Pub

Let’s talk about the tiramisu dessert from Mike’s. Better yet, let’s look at it and drool. Come in to Mike’s to watch the game and relax with a refreshing cold beer, but stay for the food. The menu features everyday favorites like pizza, salads, hoagies and so much more. Dine in, take out, or delivery is available. Save room for dessert! 

Orange Creme Ice Cream from Yellow Banks Grove | Plumlee Indian Rocks Beach Rentals

Orange Crème Ice Cream 

@Yellow Banks Grove

Yellow Banks Grove is a quaint, old-fashioned Florida citrus market. Desserts are made right at the shop. Two popular favorites are the Key Lime Pie and Orange Crème ice cream. Check it out during you next Indian Rocks Beach vacation, and let us know what you think. We want to know what you got! 

What’s your favorite dessert in indian rocks Beach?

Let us know what it is and where you get it. Drop it in the comment section below.

The Most Tempting Desserts in Indian Rocks Beach